Today, we reviewed data (evidence), warrant & claim. We discussed bricks & concrete details (evidence).
We looked at Crime & Puzzlement 2 "Slip or Trip." You should have written an IC; IC sentence and an IC, CC IC sentence about the puzzle.
Then we reviewed "Witness for the Prosecution" and watched parts of the 1957 version (which ends differently than both the story and the dramatized version!)
What is genre? it's the kind, type, "flavor" or classification of the book.
Why does genre matter? There are a specific set of rules for each type of fiction. Readers know what the rules are, based on their previous experience with that genre.
The "Drama" or "Problem" Novel A strong, interesting, believable plot that centers around a problem a young person might actually experience. Transports the reader into another person's life and problems/issues. The characters are round (dynamic) and have a balance of good and bad qualities or characteristics. The issue (problem) adds to the the story (moves the story along/is central to the plot). The story, issue, author leaves the reader with something to deeply consider, think about or ponder. The story should be smooth and it should have mass, wide, or large appeal so that it speaks to a broad audience. There should be time so that the reader has to think. Dramas have conflict. They have a resolution at the end, not a happy ending. There are 2 main characters, an antagonist (against change) and a protagonist (wants change). These are not "good guys" or "bad guys." They are simply working at an issue from different perspectives.
Science fiction must stick to natural laws.(Gravity, sound in space, etc. Time travel and faster-than-light are often ignored entirely, however.)
Laws must be clear and defined.
Most writers of science fiction are male.
Characters voyage in space. They must save the universe.
Science fiction is more action than science.
It always takes place in the future.
However, the problems are alwayscurrent.
The target audience for science fiction is male, ages 15+
Science fiction sometimes combines with fantasy.
2 kinds of this are utopian and dystopian. Utopian means a perfect world. Dystopian means amessed-up world.
A movie with a utopia in it: Star Trek
A movie with a dystopia in it: City of Ember, The Matrix, Corraline
Mystery Notes There are 6 kinds of detectives:
1. The amateur detective (examples: Nancy Drew, Scooby Doo.)These are ALTRUISTIC detectives who are solving crimes because "it's the right thing to do."
2. The Neighborhood Detective (example: Murder She Wrote, Encyclopedia Brown.) This detective solves crimes in their town as a benefit to the town. These are often amateurs and are doing it to benefit the people they live with. They take place in a specific area, have a local sheriff, and local characters---like pastor/religious leader.
3. The Private Investigator.(Examples, Magnum, P.I., Sue Graftons's Kinsey Milhone, Psych.) These detectives solve crimes they are paid to investigate. This is their job, but they could quit at any time because they are motivated by money. It's not the same as a police investigation, but the private investigator is often a former policeman or someone involved with law enforcement.
4. The "Law and Order" Detective(Examples: CSI, NCIS, Patricia Cornwell's Kay Scarpetta, James Patterson's Women's Murder Club.) These are detectives with titles (like doctor, Detective, Inspector, Crime Scene Investigator, Special Agent). They investigate crimes because "That's my job!" to uphold the law and bring criminals to "justice." They are motivated by right and wrong, legal definitions, and often led by science.
5. The SPY (Examples: Anthony Horowitz's Alex Rider, Jason Bourne from The Bourne Identity, Mission Impossible) These detectives are discovering mysteries and solving crimes that are world-wide and involve the lives and issues of entire countries. They have gadgets and rules that are above and beyond normal standards.
6. The Personal Detective (Examples: Mary Higgins Clark characters, Dan Brown's Robert Langdon, romance-mysteries) This detective is motivated by life-and-death situations where he/she MUST solve the crime to stay alive. The initial murder being investigated is personal (a loved family member or close friend) and "it's personal" and they are on a "quest" to solve an unsolved murder the police haven't been able to solve.
Satisfying mysteries follow these 6 rules
Rule ONE: (clues) All the clues MUST be in the book. No clues are left out and suddenly appear at the end of the book. We want a chance to evaluate the evidence.
Rule TWO: (crime)The crime must be significant and we must care about it to want to solve it.
Rule THREE: (criminal) The actual criminal must be introduced early into the book. While we may not know his name, we know things about him.
Rule FOUR: (detective) The detective must WORK at solving the crime. It can't be too easy or we feel cheated.
Rule FIVE: (suspects) There must be a defined list of suspects, and the actual criminal must be among them--or connected to the list.
Rule SIX:(non-sequitur)All the clues must make sense at the ending. There should be no random pieces of information (no red-herrings).
At the end, the mystery MUST be solved.
Most mysteries start "in media res" which is Latin for "in the middle" of the story.
In class we started Agatha Christie's Witness for the Prosecution and will finish it in the next class period.
Today, you get a new seating chart!
We discuss your papers (the C or better policy) and the grammar summative assessment (semi-colons, FANBOYS).
Then, we'll discuss Galileo...
And Plato...
And Aristotle...
And Socrates.
Then, you'll get copies of "Allegory of the Cave."
Read as a group. Discuss these things: Small group discussions – Choose a reporter to write down the group’s responses and report back to class when class comes back together.
Small Group Discussion Questions
Describe how the people in the cave are situated in Plato's parable. Why can't they move their legs or necks to take a look around? What is the only thing they are capable of seeing? What is their only source of light?
Would you want to be released from the cave? Why or why not?
What do these prisoners trapped in the cavern believe is real?
What is like the cave in our world?
How do the prisoners react when they first see sunlight? Why?
What are the stages of the liberated prisoner's experience outside the cave?
What does Plato’s allegory of the cave tell us about how we recognize things?
How is the way you understand the world, your ideas and beliefs, shaped by the actions of others?
What does Plato’s cave tell us about what we see with our eyes?
Who has the power to shape your ideas and beliefs? In what ways is this good and in what ways is it not so good?
What is truth according to Plato in this allegory?
Are there things you know to be true? What are they, and how do you know them?
How is it possible that people can believe in illusion and accept it as reality?
What sometimes happens to people when the illusion is shattered and reality is revealed?
Describe other "caves" in modern life in which people might be "imprisoned" or feel "imprisoned".
What happens if a prisoner is released and is compelled to look at the light? What does he see?
If the liberated prisoner goes back to the cave and tries to explain to his former fellow prisoners, what kind of reaction will he get? Why?
To what extent do you find Socrates point about human tendency to confuse "shadows" with "reality" relevant today?
What could be the elements that prevent people from seeing the truth, or regarding "shadow" as the "truth"?
What do the imagery of "shackles" and the "cave" suggest about the perspective of the cave dwellers or prisoners?
In society today or in your own life, what sorts of things shackle the mind?
Compare the perspective of the freed prisoner with the cave prisoners.
Whole group discussion
Reports from small groups
Be able to answer this: What is Plato trying to tell us in the allegory? Perception vs. reason – how can we know things about the world? Homework: Write one page discussing your ideas using what you have learned from the "Allegory of the Cave." Be sure to discuss this situation in terms of sight, vision, blindness, truth, reality, illusion, light, and dark as it is appropriate.
Today we discussed the difference between dichotomy and yin-yang. See these links. We covered the difference between Eastern & Western schools of thought on opposites.
Today, you took the formative assessment on grammar. We will review what you don't know and have a summative assessment on September 26. Then, we went over the questions. You should have turned in your 1st Thought Exercise (we went over the rough draft in class last time.) THEN, we reviewed binary opposition & chiarascuro (you had a group quiz).